About Us

Here's Why...

In 1981, Ron Thurman started a small hometown insurance agency in the desert town of Victorville, CA, called Key City Insurance.  The agency flourished over the years and in 2003 he and his son, Brent Thurman, formed a small satellite office in Provo, Utah which later became known as Keystone Insurance Services.

Armed with the example and teachings of his father, Brent and his staff continue to serve the insurance needs of homeowners, drivers, business owners, and families in Utah, Idaho, and Arizona while representing some of the most important and sought-after insurance companies, including Bear River Mutual® Insurance, Travelers®, Progressive®, The Hartford, Auto-Owners Insurance, Mutual of Enumclaw™, Safeco®, and many, many more. We have strategically aligned ourselves with the best insurance companies in several fields so we can compare rates and offer you the best coverage options and competitive rates

Since the selection of insurance companies is so broad at Keystone Insurance Services, finding the right fit for each customer’s individual needs is simple – and that’s the way it should be as an independent insurance broker.  Keystone Insurance has a staff that is knowledgeable, friendly, responsive, and  proud to be rooted in the unique community and culture found in Utah.

Whether you're a first-time buyer, switching carriers, or new to the area, call us now at (801) 515-2741 or email Quotes@Keystoneinsurance.com to get a quick customized insurance quote. We service Provo, American Fork, Orem, Lehi, Pleasant Grove, Springville, Salt Lake City, and surrounding areas.

We help families and businesses find competitive rates on comprehensive car insurance, homeowners insurance, renters insurance, commercial insurance, liability insurance, umbrella insurance, and more. Our agents compare multiple policy options to help you save money with bundling discounts, multi-policy savings, safe driver discounts, and other affordable rates.

Read about the consequences of driving without insurance in Utah.

Keystone Insurance Services was voted as one of the top home insurance providers in Provo, Utah in 2021 by Expertise.com, in addition to being recognized by Quality Business Awards in 2026 as "The leading Auto Insurance in Orem, achieving a quality score of 95%+ and representing the top 1% of American businesses," based on these criteria:

• Proven track record of exceptional service quality
• Independently verified customer satisfaction ratings
• Commitment to maintaining highest industry standards
• Trusted by the local Orem community
• Continuous improvement and professional excellence

At our full-service agency, we provide personalized insurance consultation, fast claims assistance, and expert advice to help you evaluate your coverage needs. We assist with policy changes, review coverage annually, and support you throughout the entire claims process. Contact us to schedule an appointment for a tailored insurance comparison and discover how our payment plans and flexible options make affordable protection accessible.